Why Big Businesses Spend a Fortune on Redesigns That Don't Fix Anything
It usually starts the same way. Sales are flat, someone senior says the website "looks dated", and within a few months there's a budget, an agency and a brand new platform on the way. A year later the site looks great, the bill is large, and the numbers haven't moved.
The problem is rarely the design or the platform. It's that nobody stopped to find out who the customers are and why the current site isn't working for them.
The research says this is common
SoftwareReviews, part of Info-Tech Research Group, estimates that up to 80% of website redesigns fall short of their potential (opens in a new tab). The number one reason it gives isn't technology or budget. It's failing to line the site up with what buyers actually need.
That fits what you see in practice. The brief gets written around what the leadership team wants to say, what competitors' sites look like and which platform the IT team prefers. The customer's question, "can this company solve my problem, and how do I start?", is somewhere near the bottom.
Even big brands get this wrong
Size doesn't protect you. When Snapchat redesigned its app in 2018, a petition asking for the old version back gathered more than 1.2 million signatures. A company with enormous resources changed how its core users found their friends' content without properly understanding how they used it.
Research on its own isn't a guarantee either. CXL describes how the Swiss comparison site Comparis carried out user research before a redesign (opens in a new tab) and still saw conversions fall by more than 10% after launch. Talking to customers matters, but so does measuring what changes once real visitors arrive.
A replatform is not a strategy
Moving platforms is sometimes the right call. An ageing system can be slow, insecure or impossible to update. But a new platform with the same unclear message, the same confusing journey and the same weak offer will perform exactly like the old one, just faster.
If the reason for the project is "the site isn't converting", a new platform is an expensive way to avoid asking why.
What to find out before you spend anything
Most of these answers already exist inside the business. They just never make it into the brief.
- Who are your best customers? Not everyone you'd like to sell to. The ones who already buy, stay and refer.
- What are they trying to do on your site? Get a price, check you cover their area, compare you with someone else, book a call.
- Where do they leave? Your analytics will show the pages where people drop off. That's where the problem is.
- What do your sales and support teams keep hearing? The same five questions, asked every week, are the content your site is missing.
- What do people search to find you? Search Console shows the exact words they use, which are often not the words on your site.
Often the honest answer is that the site needs three pages rewritten and one form fixed, not a six-figure rebuild.
Where we come in
When a rebuild genuinely is the answer, our website rebuild package starts from what your analytics and customers are already telling you, and maps every old URL so you don't lose rankings on the way. If you're not sure yet whether you need a rebuild at all, book a free 30 minute call and we'll tell you honestly.
Keep reading
PHP2Shell Explained: Is Your Website at Risk?
Two critical PHP flaws, patched on 21 October 2026, put any WordPress or PHP site on an old version at risk. What happened, how to check, and what to do.
What a 'Digital & AI Consultancy' Actually Does, in Plain English
If you've landed here wondering what any of this means for your business, start here. No jargon, just what each part actually covers.